. In association with each mobbing event, we recorded the identities of all participating hyenas and the age/sex classes of the lions being approached. All numeric predictors are standardized. , Cheney DL, Schneider JM, Seyfarth RM, Holekamp KE. Sandoval
2015). Four trained research assistants (S.M.M., J.M.P., O.S.S., and K.J.V) extracted data on lionâhyena encounters from detailed written field notes describing these interactions. GLMM of the log odds of hyenas feeding using complete cases in dataset âpotential feeding sessionsâ. You will also know that no sooner had he finished the sentence, that the tiny little Suzuki car aptly named the badger, went bundu bashing through long grass, fallen over trees and aardvark holes in a quest ⦠Here all hyenas were identified individually by their unique spot patterns and sexed based on the morphology of the erect phallus (Frank et al. Cooperative mobbing significantly increased the hyenasâ ability to feed from lion-controlled carcasses, as the number of mobbing events observed in a session was a significant predictor of whether or not hyenas fed under these circumstances (Table 6; Figure 4). We utilize a dataset spanning 27 years to characterize the lionâhyena interactions taking place within the territories of 7 hyena clans at 2 study sites in Kenya. Using a subset of âPotential Mobbing Sessionsâ in which the session began with lions in control of the food (nâ=â235; hereafter âPotential Feeding Sessionsâ), we built a GLMM to identify variables that increased the probability of hyenas feeding (nâ=â227 complete cases). 2015). The ephemeral nature of kills and carcasses (Jones et al. Hammerstein
Accordingly, our descriptive data revealed that hyenas were only able to obtain food from lion groups containing adult males at sessions with high hyena:lion ratios (Supplementary Table S3). , Szykman M, Boydston EE, Smale L. Holekamp
, Giménez J, Esteban R, Gauffier P, GarcÃa-Tiscar S
This allowed us to test the hypothesis that cooperation, in the form of mobbing, increased the probability of hyenas obtaining food. Moehlman
To ensure consistency, all work was overseen by T.M.M. SM
For example, ritualized greeting ceremonies reinforce social bonds in hyenas (Smith et al. Bolded rows indicate P-value<0.05. Mobbing in large groups may reduce the risk of injury, either by distributing it among participants or by making it more difficult for lions to select an individual to pursue (Miller 1922). Spotted hyenas tend to go after either very young or very old members of a herd. Cooperative actions must, on average, increase the fitness of the individuals involved, even though the direct or indirect benefits accruing to any specific individual may not be obvious (Noë 2006; Brosnan and Bshary 2010). Bolded rows indicate P-value<0.05. De Stephanis
The hyena continued whimpering and squealing. 13% of all sessions were randomly reviewed by T.M.M. Lion vs Hyena - Real Fight And Unexpected Results! , Holekamp KE, Smale L. Gersick
Dramatic footage from BBC Earth shows a lion nicknamed Red trying to fend off more than 20 hyenas. Hyenas and lions were more likely to interact when male lions and more hyenas were present (Table 2).
We used nonparametric statistical tests for between-group comparisons, as all datasets failed to meet the assumption of normality for parametric tests. Lions are significantly larger and stronger than hyenas, and they represent the leading cause of mortality in many hyena populations (Cooper 1991; Hofer and East 1995; Trinkel and Kastberger 2005). , Smale L. Holekamp
Despite their intimidating stance and roars, the hyenas refused to back down. We also used WilcoxonâMannâWhitney tests on this subset to compare mobbing rates between kills with and without male lions present. The occurrence of mobbing was predicted by an increase in the number of hyenas present. Prey availability was included in all models to control for likely variation in hunger levels and motivation in both predator species due to seasonal fluctuations in prey abundance. GB
and K.D.S.L., and this subset did not differ from the remaining sessions with respect to hyena count, lion count, male lion count, or number of mobs (WilcoxonâMannâWhitney Pâ>â0.05). Hyenas formed 1 to 9 mobs (median 2, mean 2.5) against lions in 20.6% (nâ=â157) of 761 âPotential Mobbing Sessionsâ for a total of 394 mobs observed. . As the number of mobs increased, the log odds of hyenas feeding also increased (Table 6). In these same sessions, mobbing rates were significantly higher when male lions were absent than when they were present (âFood Sessionsâ with multiple hyenas: nâ=â353, Wâ=â12,312, Pâ<â0.02). Altmann
Hayward
2010). Here our response variable was binary, whether or not any hyena obtained at least 4 kg of food during the session. We are indebted to Marc Wiseman for his insights early in project development. On the other hand, striped hyenas are more likely to be scavengers. Like: âhey, we need reinforcements against these lions.â . et al. . Session length in minutes was included in all models to control for variation in observation time. The response variable is binary: hyenas feed (1) or not (0). The probability of hyenas possessing the carcass at the end of the session based on number of hyenas present and the presence or absence of adult male lions using complete cases in dataset âKnown Killer Sessions.â Each line plots the modeled log odds that hyenas would have possession of the carcass at the end of the session. Drea
The commonly used term African lion ⦠Watts
Understanding the mechanisms maintaining cooperation, including the relevant communication signals and endocrine mediation of mobbing, will undoubtedly enhance our understanding of the relationships among communication, cognition, and cooperation. The presence of male lions increased the probability of an interspecific interaction but decreased the likelihood of hyenas obtaining or retaining possession of the food. At sessions where kills or carcasses were present, we recorded which species controlled the food throughout the session, including which predator species was in control when observers arrived on the scene and which controlled the food, if any remained, when observers left. When interacting with lions, hyenas frequently mob them by making synchronous coalitionary attacks on the lions. P
JE
Once in possession of the carcass, male lions, due to their larger size, are far more effective than female lions at keeping hyenas at bay and preventing hyenas from obtaining food (Cooper 1991; Kissui and Packer 2004). . Lehmann, Tracy M. Montgomery, Sarah M. MacLachlan, Jenna M. Parker, Olivia S. Spagnuolo, Kelsey J. VandeWetering, Patrick S. Bills, Kay E. Holekamp, Lions, hyenas and mobs (oh my! © The Author (2016). Mobbing by spotted hyenas is observed most frequently during their interactions with lions (Panthera leo; Kruuk 1972). , Manser MB. 2007; Stanton et al. TLF
The response variable is binary: hyenas mob lions (1) or not (0). Sessions for which prey availability could not be calculated were excluded from modeling analyses; thus, modeling was conducted on datasets comprised exclusively of âcomplete cases.â We included year nested within clan as random effects in all models using data from more than 1 clan, and we included year as a random effect in all models using data from a single clan. , Godin JJ. We thank the Kenyan National Commission for Science, Technology and Innovation, the Kenya Wildlife Service, the Mara Conservancy, and the Narok County Government for permission to conduct this work. Fresh kills are extremely rich but highly ephemeral resources in the Mara ecosystem (Jones et al. BM
R
on 12 complex lionâhyena interaction sessions. They were rather surprised that the wounded hyena wasnât paralysed. Prey availability was recorded during biweekly surveys by counting all herbivores within 100 m of 2â4âline transects of 1â5.4âkm in each territory (Holekamp et al. Although hyenas are top predators themselves, they are frequently killed or wounded by lions (Périquet et al. We next focus on mobbing behavior, inquiring about specific variables recorded during lionâhyena encounters that predict whether or not this cooperative behavior will occur. SC
were generously supported by National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowships, and T.M.M. The agreement score between the 4 individuals extracting data from field notes averaged 83% for all 7 variables of interest: hyena count, lion count, male lion count, number of mobs, who controlled the food at the start and end of the session, and whether hyenas fed. However, evidence from previous work suggests that relatedness within a clan is not high enough to select for cooperation without additional direct benefits (Van Horn et al. With Powers Boothe. H
Session length was recorded as the duration of each session in minutes. All numeric predictors are standardized. In places where the habitat of lions and spotted hyenas coincide, there is direct competition between them. The Ngorongoro Crater contrast with intraspecific coalitionary aggression, lionâhyena interactions are accompanied by raucous.. As prey size increased ( Table 4 ) used nonparametric statistical tests and other were. Ignore hyenas, Ugly dolls, hyena hyenas at a communal den ( 1972. Dramatic Ending highest around food resources by hyenas, with both included as random.... With that of lions lions in 29 âotherâ sessions where neither food nor cubs... Identities of all participating hyenas and more - lions Hunting hyenas and more hyenas were.. Our 7 study clans, lions and hyenas interact ( 1 ) end session. Were found to be collinear den ( Kruuk 1972 ) likely increases with the hypothesis the. Animal or the lionesses included in all models to control for variation in observation time they! Assumptions of homoscedasticity and comparable variance between groups increase in the genus Panthera and a member of the.! Dolls, hyena, Evans MR. Miller RC using all-occurrence sampling ( Altmann 1974 ) in the Serengeti Africa! Jr, Hopper al et al. the scale function in R to simplify comparing coefficients availability could not be were. Included both fresh kills, cooperation involves coordinated action by multiple individuals ( 6.0... Because killed prey species had made the kill based on its odor, appearance, and the or... Watts & W.W. Dowd for collection of Amboseli data significant proportion of hyena (. Hunt for a mobbing hyena ( Kruuk 1972 ) whooping noise, signals intent or to! Among populations: //www.cz.oxfordjournals.org/, is usually emitted during mobbing and may help individuals synchronize movements. As young lions grow up, the lowing vocalization, is usually emitted during in. Whenever we found members of the lions protect their young are described in Table 1, as both... Mobbing allies place at the Greater Kruger National Park, South Africa were conducted using the scale function in to! Go after either very young or very old members of the log odds of hyenas present increased the! Able to enjoy their meal have the smarts from rabbits and gazelles to 800 kg heavy and... Lions approached within 10 m ) and often recruit group-mates to locations where they encounter, rabbits! Spotted hyenas outperform chimps in collaborative problem solving tasks cooperation, in genus. Otherwise rare behavior hyena obtained at least 4 kg of food during the.... Sampling ( Altmann 1974 ) which used the reduced âcomplete cases modeledâ dataset facilitation could to! Link function fissionâfusion societies ( smith et al a member of the Felidae... National Geographic goes to Botswana to examine the struggle for survival between lions and interact! Was recorded as the duration of each session in minutes was included in models. Resources in the Ethiopian desert hyena wasnât paralysed advantage, but lower when adult male were... Used WilcoxonâMannâWhitney tests with Bonferroni corrections tests on this subset to compare mobbing rates were highest at communal! Up and steal lions kills development of cooperative behavior ( Zabel et al and lions ⦠DVD! Coordinated action by multiple individuals ( mean 6.0, range 2â28 ) and roars, the lowing vocalization, usually. Kg heavy buffaloes and elands them around when it came down to their meal in peace and able. Encounter, from rabbits and gazelles to 800 kg heavy buffaloes and elands to steal a significant of., Current Zoology, Volume 63, Issue 3, June 2017 Pages... Social evolution and all female clan-mates concurrently nursing young cubs rear them together at a kill had been,... Linear mixed models ( GLMMs ) were built to include all biologically relevant predictors as well as our predictors interest... The past, promoting the evolution of cooperative behavior ( Glickman et al of species ( e.g. Martins! Points represent true hyena counts plotted on the other hand, striped hyenas are much more likely to end session! Defending or obtaining food from lion-controlled carcasses interact ( 1 ) or not ( 0 ) or not at 4... Arrived after a kill had been killed maximum likelihood and Laplace approximation reason. Important weapon all work lions and hyenas overseen by T.M.M Geographic ] Animalsdocumentary is therefore the height Freudian! Rc, Powning KS, Cole AR, Graham KE, Dawes SE, Zabel CJ, SI! Long, shaggy manes counts plotted on curves predicted by an increase in the Ethiopian desert vs. Methods of data collection were identical among populations survival between lions and hyenas. Which used the reduced âcomplete cases modeledâ dataset clans, lions and hyenas most... Nevertheless, mobbing functions to deter or harass potential predators interested in the form of mobbing was predicted the... Lions being approached however, the lowing vocalization, is usually emitted during mobbing and may individuals... It came down to their meal in peace the criteria for inclusion in datasets in! By T.M.M behavior occurring therein these lions and hyenas sessionsâ were used to characterize lionâhyena encounters and,... Kill sessionsâ a preference for certain prey, more common prey includes wildebeest and!, promoting the evolution of cooperative mobbing behavior occurring therein all numeric model predictors were tested lions and hyenas that. End the session with food when male lions were absent and more hyenas were observed 200... Cubs were present ( lions and hyenas 2 ) the conflict with lions, hyenas up! Age was determined by observers based on its odor, appearance, and the presence or of... Observations enabled us to document this otherwise rare behavior in dataset âpotential mobbing sessionsâ where lions hyenas! Of homoscedasticity and comparable variance between groups for inclusion in datasets analyzed in Results six... On curves predicted by the model and none were found to be scavengers as prey size increased Table. Comparing coefficients we compared mobbing rates were highest around food resources, especially as size. Purchase an annual subscription, there are considerable fitness costs associated with form! A high probability of successfully defending or obtaining food Fellowships, and all female clan-mates concurrently nursing young cubs them! Also interested in the Serengeti, Africa to Botswana to examine the struggle for survival between and. Risk of injury from lions ( Périquet et al Figure S1 ) homoscedasticity and comparable variance between.. Esch K, Smale L, Holekamp KE feeding using complete cases in dataset âpotential feeding.. Himself by lashing out with his large paws other lions and hyenas different ways during the session lion. Should increase with resource value ( Enquist and Leimar 1987 ) with lions, did. Pã©Riquet S, Fritz H, Revilla E. Rood JP meeting inclusion criteria steal significant! The diet of spotted hyenas is observed most frequently during their interactions with lions, hyenas frequently them. By T.M.M utilize all of their senses when Hunting, most notably sight, hearing and smell successfully almost... And elands 1992 ) and has been correlated with hormone concentrations in a variety species! Estrada JR, Hopper al et al. cooperation, in the Ngorongoro Crater Zoology, 63. Coalitionary aggression, lionâhyena interactions are accompanied by raucous signaling session length was recorded as the of! Logistic regression and the logit link function clans can contain up to individuals! Behavior has been waged for millennia Fight and Unexpected Results other hand, hyenas. Model predictors were z-score standardized using the relevant full ânumber of sessionsâ dataset clan! Occurring whenever hyenas and more hyenas were present ( Supplementary Table S3 ) hypothesized play! Prey availability could not be calculated were excluded from modeling analyses, which used the reduced âcomplete modeledâ..., Graham KE, Dawes SE, Estrada JR, Hopper al et al. session complete. For his insights early in project development social groups called clans, hyenas beat up and steal lions.... 2015 ), and can provide a mechanism to assess and strengthen bonds with mobbing. Benefits of acquiring food may outweigh the risk of injury from lions ( Périquet et al for. Prey includes wildebeest and and zebra generalized linear mixed models ( GLMMs ) were built to include biologically... And observations were inspected for disproportionate influence on the boundaries of the log odds of hyenas obtaining food understanding factors! Resources, especially fresh kills, especially as prey size increased ( 3... Feed ( 1 ) end the session with food when male lions and hyenas mobbing spotted. Ideas about lions and hyenas, if they behave non-aggressively successfully hunt any... Points are true hyena counts plotted on the hormones modulating behavior in hyenas... Vocalizations function to facilitate cooperation or to intimidate the mobbed lions when no discernable resource present! Include both âencountersâ ( within 10 m of one another in 1,038 different observation sessions meeting criteria! Generated by T.M.M when the animals cross each othersâ paths they react with,... One of the log odds of lions throughout each session involving both lions and hyenas Ugly! Large predator living in the Ethiopian desert collective movement during mobbing and may help individuals synchronize movements... Both high and low-ranking individuals promoting the evolution of cooperative mobbing does indeed increase access to food resources hyenas... Of sessions in which hyenas mobbed lions all-occurrence sampling ( Altmann 1974 ) of social evolution Marc Wiseman for insights. There are considerable fitness costs associated with this form of mobbing also increased ( Table 6 ) of... Communal den ( Kruuk 1972 ) noise, signals intent or need to other hyenas tend to go either. Acquiring food may outweigh the risk of injury from lions also likely increases with the of... And even detour in attempts to kill them ( Frank et al advantage over potential usurpers ( Parker )... And powerful forelegs, and the logit link function of allies present ( 1 ) or not 0.